2024: Patrick Mahomes (QB - Kansas City Chiefs)
2023: Patrick Mahomes (QB - Kansas City Chiefs)
2022: Cooper Kupp (WR - Los Angeles Rams)
2021: Tom Brady (QB - Tampa Bay Bucaneers)
2020: Patrick Mahomes (QB - Kansas City Chiefs)
2019: Julian Edelman (WR - New England Patriots)
2018: Nick Foles (QB - Philadelphia Eagles)
2017: Tom Brady (QB - New England Patriots)
2016: Von Miller (OLB - Denver Broncos)
2015: Tom Brady (QB - New England Patriots)
2014: Malcolm Smith (MLB - Seattle Seahawks)
2013: Joe Flacco (QB - Baltimore Ravens)
2012: Eli Manning (QB - New York Giants)
2011: Aaron Rodgers (QB - Green Bay Packers)
2010: Drew Brees (QB - New Orleans Saints)
2009: Santonio Holmes (WR - Pittsburgh Steelers)
2008: Eli Manning (QB - New York Giants)
2007: Peyton Mannings (QB - Indianapolis Colts)
2006: Hines Ward (WR - Pittsburgh Steelers)
2005: Deion Branch (WR - New England Patriots)
2004: Tom Brady (QB - New England Patriots)
2003: Dexter Jackson (FS - Tampa Bay Bucaneers)
2002: Tom Brady (QB - New England Patriots)
2001: Ray Lewis (MLB - Baltimore Ravens)
2000: Kurt Warner (QB - St Louis Rams)
1999: John Elway (QB - Denver Broncos)
1998: Terrell Davis (RB - Denver Broncos)
1997: Desmond Howard (WR - Green Bay Packers)
1996: Larry Brown (RCB - Dallas Cowboys)
1995: Steve Young (QB - San Fransisco 49ers)
1994: Emmitt Smith (RB - Dallas Cowboys)
1993: Troy Aikman (QB - Dallas Cowboys)
1992: Mark Rypien (QB - Washington Redskins)
1991: Ottis Anderson (RB - New York Giants)
1990: Joe Montana (QB - San Fransisco 49ers)
1989: Jerry Rice (WR - San Fransisco 49ers)
1988: Doug Williams (QB - Washington Redskins)
1987: Phil Simms (QB - New York Giants)
1986: Richard Dent (RDE - Chicago Bears)
1985: Joe Montana (QB - San Fransisco 49ers)
1984: Marcus Allen (RB - Los Angeles Raiders)
1983: John Riggins (FB - Washington Redskins)
1982: Joe Montana (QB - San Fransisco 49ers)
1981: Jim Plunkett (QB - Oakland Raiders)
1980: Terry Bradshaw (QB - Pittsburgh Steelers)
1979: Terry Bradshaw (QB - Pittsburgh Steelers)
1978: Randy White (RDT - Dallas Cowboys) & Harvey Martin (RDE - Dallas Cowboys)
1977: Fred Biletnikoff (WR - Oakland Raiders)
1976: Lydd Swann (WR - Pittsburgh Steelers)
1975: Franco Harris (FB - Pittsburgh Steelers)
1974: Larry Csonka (FB - Miami Dolphins)
1973: Jake Scott (FS - Miami Dolphins)
1972: Roger Staubach (QB - Dallas Cowboys)
1971: Chuck Howley (LLB - Dallas Cowboys)
1970: Len Dawson (QB - Kansas City Chiefs)
1969: Joe Namath (QB - New York Jets)
1968: Bart Starr (QB - Green Bay Packers)
1967: Bart Starr (QB - Green Bay Packers)